Comparing 3 Moulding Materials: Wood, MDF, and PVC

October 14, 2024

Choosing the proper moulding for one’s home is more than simply aesthetics. Materials utilized will greatly influence the durability, functionality, and the aesthetics of the final product. Here at Smith & DeShields, many options are available regarding mouldings, with the most popular are those made from wood, MDF, and PVC. The strange and useful variations that each one presents make it important to understand the differences between them. How, precisely, do these materials compare?

1. Wood Moulding

Wood has always been a classic material that adds warmth and a touch of nature to every room. Wood works really well in intricate designs and custom profiles, and given its versatility is unmatched. These mouldings come in many species, with pine being the most common, although oak and poplar are also used. Mouldings can be stained or painted. While wood provides strength and authenticity, it has its drawbacks, too, in the form of higher costs compared to other materials. Wood may also require regular maintenance in order to avoid warping or damage due to moisture, especially in highly humid areas.

Pros: Natural beauty, durable, customizable, can be stained or painted.
Cons: Higher cost, susceptible to warping or moisture damage, requires more maintenance.

2. MDF Moulding

MDF. (medium-density fiberboard) is a common substitute for wood. It is known for its smooth, even finish. MDF is comprised of wood fibers combined with resin and thereby tends to be quite easy and inexpensive to work with. MDF moulding is normally pre-primed to save time in finishing and is great for painted applications. It is less durable than wood and has some vulnerability to water damage. Therefore it is not the best choice for bathrooms and other areas prone to moisture.

Pros: Cost-efficient, smooth surface, ideal for painted finishes, easy to install.
Cons: Less durable than wood, prone to water damage, not ideal for high-moisture areas.

3. PVC Molding

PVC moulding is a type of moulding made from a solid plastic material perfect for wet areas, such as bathrooms and kitchens, and even outdoors. Unlike wood and MDF, it will not rot, become infested with insects, or warp, and hence, requires less maintenance. It can be painted, though many enjoy the sleek, plain white finish it comes in. While vinyl is more resilient, it lacks the organic warmth of wood, and for some design aesthetics, a homeowner may desire a more traditional look for their home.

Pros: Moisture-resistant, durable, low maintenance, rot- and insect-resistant.
Cons: Less traditional look, limited finish options, can be more expensive than MDF.

Smith & DeShields

Choose from an unparalleled selection of doors, hardware, moulding and other architectural accents, as well as building supplies. Many of these are in stock, available immediately and are locally exclusive to Smith & DeShields. Quality permeates every facet of our business and it’s no different when it comes to choosing top-quality hardware.

For over 67 years, Smith & DeShields has been well-respected for evolving its product lines to match the latest technology, designs and hardware that stand the test of time. Contractors, architects, and homeowners alike are invited to experience the wide variety of quality products showcased in each of our four Florida showrooms. Visit SmithandDeShields.com to learn more.